Listen to the information in the description for Digby. It says it runs half a size small so I'm an 8.5 but I got a 9 and they fit lovely. The quality is impeccable, these are my first pair of Jeffrey Campbell's and they are flawless. They will have to be broken in just because the black leather is tough so I can see that I'll have to wear socks or else I'll blister, kind of like buying a new pair of Docs. First time ordering from this site as well and great customer service.